Learn From 15 Ebay PowerSellers How They Raked In Over $11,726,200 Last Year Alone
Does everyone give eBay positive feedback?
At some point everyone has heard an eBay horror story. Stories much like this one:
Alan Thomasson, a student at the University of Lincoln, was looking to buy a new guitar. So, like millions of others, he went to ‘the UK’s largest online marketplace’ – eBay. Like millions of others, he browsed the items up for sale before finally deciding on a ‘nearly-new’ Fender Stratocaster. He used PayPal, eBay’s official online payment service, and coughed up the £300 needed for his new six-string. A week passed, and Alan hadn’t heard a peep from the seller. Like any other self-respecting buyer he emailed the seller and asked where his guitar was. He was told it was on the way and not to worry. Another week passed. Then another. Alan emailed eBay asking them to help with his missing guitar, but all they told him was to email the seller and work it out between themselves. Eventually Alan took matters into his own hands. He managed to find the seller’s address from one of the emails he’d received, and as it turned out the seller was a mere 30 miles away! Alan and a couple of friends (for moral support) drove to the seller’s house, knocked on his door, and asked for the guitar or the money. The seller was reluctant, but not aggressive. He took on an ‘it’s a fair cop’ attitude, and refunded Alan’s money via PayPal right then and there.
It’s safe to say that eBay is one website Alan won’t be bookmarking!
Stories just like this one have been floating around the internet and general media since eBay was founded in California, USA way back in September 1995 – then known as ‘AuctionWeb’. The company’s founder, computer programmer Pierre Omidyar, tried to rename the website ‘EchoBay’ however the name was taken so he resorted to his second choice – the world renowned ‘eBay’. The idea of a ‘virtual marketplace’ took the world by storm and in a matter of a few years eBay was world leader of the online auctions market, spawning countless ‘clone sites’ ever since.
According to eBay’s official figures, they have a global customer base of 181 million users. That’s a lot of auctions. 78 million auctions at any given moment to be precise. With that many users buying and selling that many items, there are bound to be some unhappy customers, right? That’s exactly what this article is all about; how many people really do give eBay ‘positive feedback’?
To get a general idea, I asked a cross-section of people whether their experience of eBay had been a generally positive or negative one. Out of the seventy people asked, only 15% of them said they’d had a generally negative experience. If we look at that as an indicator of the global market, that’s a staggering 27,150,000 unhappy customers. Obviously it’s not practical to see the results of seventy as the results of the whole world, but it gives you an idea.
So, if there are so many people who aren’t so happy with eBay – where can we find them? Well, a good place to start looking would be anti-eBay website ‘FireMeg.com’. The name refers to the current CEO & President of eBay, Meg Whitman. Members of the website believe that she is the cause of much of the discontent in the eBay community, and are working towards, as the name suggests, have her fired. I talked to the founder of FireMeg.com, Josh Shaffer.
I wondered what the initial motivation behind the website was.
“It wasn’t one singular event, but rather many little issues that culminated in my decision to start the site. My wife and I have been selling on eBay, full-time, for four years now. I had been selling off-and-on for about four years before that.” Josh told me “I was prompted to ‘attack’ CEO Meg Whitman because many of the issues aside from glitches (fraud, scams, investments, etc.) seem to point directly back to her as the perpetuator of problems.”
Josh continued to speak about the increase in ‘seller fees’ (eBay charge users to sell their items and take a cut of the profit) over the past two years. He even claims that the biggest gripe his group has with eBay is their “lies and deceit”. This refers to eBay stating on more than one occasion this year that there would be no more seller fee increases.
Last June at ‘eBay Live’, an annual eBay convention held in Las Vegas, Meg Whitman made a speech regarding the future of eBay’s sellers. Josh was quick to point out that Meg did not once mention an increase in seller fees. Then, a month later, eBay announced a fee increase which “caught [sellers] completely off-guard”. The site ‘glitches’ that Josh told me about are also a major concern, especially when eBay phone reps have, according to Mr Shaffer, been caught lying to users. As Josh puts it “eBay’s view on glitches is until it becomes a site-wide glitch affecting nearly all of the users, both buyers and sellers, that it isn’t really a glitch.”
So, what do you think? Are eBay swindling their customers or do you think there’ll always be a few unhappy customers? Would you give eBay positive or negative feedback?
One important thing to remember in a case like this is that eBay is a worldwide company. Every day they have to deal with complaints about fraud, deception, glitches and a range of other issues. Whilst doing this they have to maintain the cost of running all of their global sites. That includes a full payroll - from web technicians to ‘Live Help’ reps.
In the world of business there’ll always be an eBay and there’ll always be a FireMeg.com. Some, much like myself, would rather sit on the fence and enjoy one of the 85% of transactions that seem to run without a hitch.
If I ever find myself in that 15%, though, you can be sure Mr Shaffer will be the first person I’ll call!

